Artificial sweeteners mess with our microbes!

I took this photo in the ski resort town of Whistler, British Columbia, Canada. It was part of an immersive, multimedia night walk through the old-growth forests of Cougar Mountain. The sign immediately made me think of the confusing messages that artificial sweeteners send to our brain and body.

What’s Missing from Modern Medicine is understanding that artificial sweeteners are NOT the inert substances they were once believed to be.

They do NOT just travel through our body untouched.

They touch the many taste receptors and chemoreceptors found throughout our body, and they negatively impact our:

  • Gut microbiota — the trillions of bacteria that live in our gut
  • Metabolism — how we extract energy from food and drinks
  • Blood sugar regulation — thereby increasing the risk of type 2 diabetes
  • Ability to control our hunger — thereby increasing the risk of obesity
  • And taste perception — leading to an increased preference for sweet foods, and making real food taste more bland.

Last week I went into great detail describing the different types of artificial sweeteners — also known as non-nutritive or low calorie-no calorie sweeteners — to lay the foundations for what I talk about today.

If you missed last week’s episode, I highly recommend you go back and listen to it first, because you’ll find it much easier to follow what I say today.

And before we continue with the science, it’s worth delving into the intriguing history of a few artificial sweeteners, starting with SACCHARIN, because it illustrates our absolute obsession with sweetness, and the controversies that have characterised artificial sweeteners from the outset.

The discovery of saccharin in 1878 triggered one of the most toxic bitter feuds (pun intended) in the history of science. It pitted a prominent university professor, Ira Remsen, against his junior post-doctoral fellow, Constantin Fahlberg, in a battle over fame, money, and intellectual property.

One fateful evening in 1879, when Fahlberg sat down to eat, he noticed that the piece of bread he was holding tasted unusually sweet. Apparently he didn’t wash his hands before he ate, so he immediately suspected that a chemical on his fingers had contaminated the bread.

Excitedly, Fahlberg returned to the laboratory and began tasting all the compounds he’d been handling that day. Might I mention that he was working with coal-tar derivates. Not exactly what I’d have on my buffet table. But that was how he discovered that saccharin — an industrial fossil-fuel hydrocarbon — was sweet.

When he told his boss, Remsen, about the discovery, they immediately co-authored and published academic papers to announce the wonder substance to the scientific world. And in those papers, both men received equal credit.

Shortly after the papers were published, Fahlberg left Johns Hopkins and started thinking about the massive commercial potential of a calorie-free substance that was 300 times sweeter than sugar …

* * * * *

Thirty-five years after the discovery of saccharin, a study published in the prestigious journal Nature investigated whether artificial sweeteners — specifically saccharin, sucralose and aspartame — could affect the body’s ability to control blood sugar by changing the bacteria living in our gut.

In experiments with mice, the researchers found that those consuming these sweeteners developed higher blood-glucose levels than mice consuming sugar!

When the researchers gave the mice antibiotics to reduce their gut bacteria, the effect disappeared. This strongly suggested that microbes play an important role in the negative impact of consuming artificial sweeteners.

To investigate further, the researchers then transferred gut bacteria from the mice fed artificial sweeteners into mice that had no gut microbes of their own. These are known as ‘germ-free mice’ and they’re laboratory mice that are born and raised in sterile bubbles, specifically for the purpose of studying the effect of introducing microbes.

Sure enough, the recipient mice also developed higher blood-glucose levels — ie the mice receiving faecal matter from mice fed artificial sweeteners also experienced blood glucose problems. And analyses confirmed that the bacterial communities in artificial sweetener mice had changed, including an increase in genes involved in breaking down carbohydrates.

Ongoing experiments in humans have also confirmed that saccharin, sucralose and aspartame can affect blood-glucose regulation by changing the gut microbiome in a way that CONTRIBUTES to metabolic problems rather than prevents them.

* * * * *

Today I’m going to answer two similar whether questions — one from Colin and one from Fran.

Colin optimistically implored:

Please assure me whether soft drinks labelled SUGAR FREE are OK to drink!

And Fran asked:

After your episode on sugary drinks, can you tell me whether sugar-FREE and DIET soft drinks are a better choice?

I’ll let you decide for yourself after listening to today’s episode.

* * * * *

Click here to watch the episode on my YouTube channel, or listen to Healing with Dr Helena on your preferred podcast platform. I’ll publish a new episode every Monday, and you’ll receive an email notification that morning. Please subscribe to my podcast or YouTube channel so that you don’t miss an episode, and send your whether questions to: podcast@drhelenapopovic.com

If you’re happy for me to play your voice on my podcast, you can provide an audio file. Otherwise, you can type your question for me to read out.

I very much look forward to answering your questions, and exploring how we can all build a smarter brain, stronger body and deeply fulfilling life.

Please share this Health-e-Byte with everyone you know!

Leave a Comment

Contact Us

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you asap.

Not readable? Change text. captcha txt